Allstate said Wednesday that its auto insurance business declined in profitability in the last three months of 2014, but overall did about the same in 2014 as 2013….
Four bills relevant to collision repair were held for further study Tuesday after what the Providence Journal reported was a two-hour, well-attended hearing before the Corporations Committee.
The Journal described it as the “annual fight” over auto insurance and repair. Rhode Island has a history of bills favorable to the auto body, so much so that the Property Casualty Insurers of America issued a special report attacking a local collision repair association (and Repairer Driven News to offer a few counterargument statistics that PCI omitted).
These include February’s House 5471, which opens the door for third-party insurance lawsuits against insurers that “engage in unfair claims settlement practices and unfair and deceptive competition and practices.”
That means auto body shops (and anybody else) can go after insurers with lawsuits that might otherwise have been denied in court on the grounds that a collision repairer isn’t technically the one with the policy in question. (Even if an insurer’s handling of it very much affects them.)
The Journal noted this was possibly “the most heavily vetted” legislation at the meeting.
Auto Body Association of Rhode Island lobbyist Peter Petrarca said that third parties, including those whose property was damaged by an insurer’s policyholder, are frequently “pushed to the side,” according to the Journal.
PCI state government relations Vice President Frank O’Brien said that litigation would increase premiums, according to the Journal. PCI also has estimated similar bills in 2011 would have increased auto insurance rates by as much as $215 if they’d passed, citing data partially derived using a 2010 Berkeley Research Group study of bad-faith lawsuits.
However, Rhode Island requires approval for any rate increases of more than 5 percent, and a more than 18 percent bump in average rates (based on 2012 numbers used in that report) for policyholders getting liability, collision and comprehensive insurance, would probably not be an easy sell to state officials.
(Also, auto insurance was still profitable for state insurers in 2012, though the tough competition these days seems to be rendering it more of a loss leader.)
“With all due respect, I’m an attorney, and if you’re not doing something wrong, you shouldn’t be worried about litigation costs,” Petrarca said, a ccording to the Journal report.
Also on the agenda for the Rhode Island Assembly Corporations Committee on Tuesday:
- House 5491, which would create two tiers of auto body shops recognized by the state, “Class A” and “Class B” — and require insurers to provide different labor rate surveys for both levels. Read our earlier analysis of it here.
- House 5607, which licenses auto glass shops.
- House 5783, which alters a definition of “aftermarket part” to any non-OEM part on a vehicle, not just on the body.
Be heard: Rhode Island legislator contact information can be found here.
Providence Journal, March 25, 2015
Featured image: The Rhode Island Capitol is shown. (tupungato/iStock/Thinkstock)