Repairer Driven News
« Back « PREV Article  |  NEXT Article »
Collision Industry Conference Chairman Randy Stabler speaks at the April 2015 CIC. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)

CIC seeks members for insurer-repairer relations panel revamp

By on
Announcements | Associations | Education | Insurance | Repair Operations

Seeking to include perspectives from other elements of the collision repair ecosystem, the Collision Industry Conference put out a call Monday for new Insurer-Repairer Relations Committee members.

“While the current committee members continue to do great work, there is a need to incorporate additional perspectives and expand the current committee’s diversity to include repair facilities, insurance providers, data providers, rental providers, customer experience experts, quality assurance/certification experts, etc..,” CIC Chairman Randy Stabler wrote in a Chairman’s Note to the CIC membership Monday.

Allstate claims Director Clint Marlow will chair the committee, Stabler wrote.

The committee’s goal is obvious from its name: “Improve the relationship between insurers and repairers,” as a 2015 committee presentation puts it. This year, Stabler wants to focus on how each business participating in a collision repair claim adds value to the customer and the other companies with which it did business.

“I have often spoke about the benefit of the customer feeling that they have obtained additional value and feel strongly that a good first step for the committee is to develop a shared understanding of what efforts are typically viewed as adding value and how they would be measured,” Stabler wrote.

Anyone interested in joining the revamped committee should email Stabler at or Marlow at

“I understand that the pace of our work is often hectic and how a rational of ‘I don’t have time’ could be used to explain why you are unable to participate,” Stabler wrote. “I encourage you to dig deep and become involved!”

Asked if those on the present committee could still serve on the retooled one, Stabler wrote that while he would provide input, the decision of who was in the body was up to Marlow as the chairman.

“I have talked to him about getting fresh ideas and the desire to have a cross section of the industry represented on his committee,” Stabler wrote.

Though the Insurer-Repairer relations Committee had what seemed to be a productive discussion on how to better calculate customer ETAs at the July CIC in Detroit, it was largely absent from agendas in 2015. Unfortunately, that was a year in which the two interests really didn’t get along, based on the slew of antitrust lawsuits filed by collision repairers nationwide against insurers, and could have used a little relationship rebuilding.

The Collision Industry Conference Insurer-Repairer Relations Committee at the July CIC. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)

The shakeup comes a month after CIC’s Marketing Committee warned the body granularity, insularity and inactivity threatened its survival.

The CIC must attract new voices — including consistent attendance from the top 10 insurers — notice new technology and actually act on the same feedback collected over and over again, the Marketing Committee concluded.

“The audience and the content has not changed for a year,” Questback sales and marketing Vice President Chris Brandl told the CIC while discussing feedback survey responses.

For the record, here’s the 2015 committee, according to a CIC PowerPoint:

  • Aaron Schulenburg, SCRS
  • Al Estorga, Estorga’s
  • Anthony Klein, eSurance
  • Barry Dorn, Dorn’s AutoBody
  • Bill Bebinger, Nationwide
  • Bill Lawrence, LC Automotive
  • Bob Smith, Repair Advocate
  • Brett Downs, 1800Radiator
  • Carl Garcia, Carl’s Collision
  • Chris Andreoli, Progressive
  • Chris Donnelly, Bodyworks Collision
  • Chris Northup, G, D and C
  • Darrell Amberson, LaMettry’s
  • Derrick Garza, CynCast
  • Domenic Brusco, PPG
  • Doug Graff, State Farm
  • Doug Irish, VeriFacts (Chairman)
  • Erik Sumen, Class Auto
  • Farzam Afshar, VeriFacts
  • Frank Laviola, Enterprise Leasing
  • Gary Wano, G W and Sons
  • Guy Maniscalo, Collision Centers of America
  • Joe Lacy, GEICO
  • Joe Laurentino, Esurance
  • John Palumbo, Parts Channel
  • John Prozinski, ASI Claims
  • John Vito, Hertz
  • Jordan Hendler, WMABA
  • Kevork Kahwajian, Fix Auto
  • Liz Stein, APN
  • Marcy Tieger, Symphony Advisors
  • Mark Allen, Audi
  • Mark Houde, The Traveler’s
  • Mike Condon, Condon Consulting
  • Mike Lloyd, California Casualty
  • Mike Manika, CarFax
  • Michael Quinn, u-Parts
  • Patrick O’Neill, Body Shop Revolution
  • Peter James, ICC Group
  • Randy Hanson, Allstate (Chairman)
  • Richard Perry, Chief
  • Rod Enlow, CCAR
  • Ron Vincenzi, Oakland Auto Body
  • Russell Thrall, Quandec
  • Vatche Derderian, Fix Auto Pasadena and Whittier


Collision Industry Conference Chairman Randy Stabler speaks at the April 2015 CIC. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)

The Collision Industry Conference Insurer-Repairer Relations Committee at the July CIC. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)