A Mercedes dealership accused of demanding a “mafia-style bribe” from a New York body shop in exchange for renewing an OEM certification sponsorship has fired…
Magnesium might not be as popular for lightweighting as steel alternatives like composites or aluminum (or more advanced steel), but it’s crucial that technicians understand what to do — and not do — when they encounter it.
FCA has warned collision repairers to never grind the magnesium Pacifica liftgate inner (seen in yellow in the color-coded body-in-white photographs above and below) or any other part containing the metal, given the “highly combustible” nature of the ensuing residue.
Protect yourself and your colleagues. Listen to FCA and don’t grind or repair the part. The inner liftgate is replace-only; FCA even titles one discussion of it with “DO NOT REPAIR” in bold and capital letters.
The only procedures allowed are “for refinishing purposes,” must be “done with a scuff pad not a sanding disc” and must follow paint manufacturer recommendations, according to FCA. The only thing close to an exception: “On the liftgate inner panel, with the use of 80 grit sand paper, remove all adhesive from the area where the structural adhesive will be applied. The metal should be completely bare.”
And make sure overly zealous work on the aluminum outer doesn’t lead a technician to mistakenly start grinding the magnesium inner, FCA warns.
“When grinding the liftgate outer panel hem flange stop immediately upon perforation,” FCA warns, then repeats its earlier point. “This will prevent any grinding on the magnesium liftgate inner panel which should not be ground at all.”
FCA also directs technicians not to worry about the magnesium’s texture — it’s supposed to look like that. (So again, no grinding.)
• The textured finish differs from a smooth finish typically found on closure panels.
• The texture is produced from the casting of the component as compared to smooth stamped sheet metal.
• This finish is completely normal and acceptable.
• Do not remove the textured finish to produce a smooth finished appearance.
Should a technician start a magnesium fire by violating these rules, shops should use a D-class extinguisher — one intended to put out burning metals — to knock it down, FCA advises. Throwing water on the fire can react with the magnesium to create magnesium oxide and hydrogen gas and make the blaze far worse. Also, don’t look directly at burning magnesium, or you’ll risk eye damage.
The liftgate also should not be exposed to temperature above 500 degrees (260 Celsius), and certainly not to open flame (which is much hotter), FCA warns.
Fun fact: Unlike higher-strength steels, which grow weaker when exposed to heat, magnesium is quite resilient in this regard, according to FCA. So the temperature warning appears to be intended more at protecting shops from fires than the structural integrity of the magnesium.
“Magnesium loses some of its tensile strength when exposed to such extreme heat – a condition that does not occur in normal driving,” FCA safety and engineering spokesman Eric Mayne wrote in an email. “However, the material recovers this strength when cooled back to ambient. It’s noteworthy that to increase magnesium’s temperature by 1C, you must apply twice as much heat than would be required for an equal mass of steel. This speaks to magnesium’s capacity as a heat sink.”
Magnesium’s ignition temperature is higher than 500 degrees, but as the powder is a major combustion hazard — it can even spontaneously combust — FCA probably doesn’t want to take any chances, and neither should a shop.
Larger bulks of magnesium can prevent ignition, according to a CanmetMATERIALS researcher in an Advanced Materials & Process article, which at least in part probably explains why FCA calls the residue a combustion threat but says a liftgate damaged in a collision isn’t.
“The material used in the Pacifica’s lift gate inner panel is an alloy, of which magnesium is the primary component,” Mayne wrote. “Regardless, magnesium in this form does not pose an ignition risk. Vehicles that contain magnesium benefit from significant weight reduction. The material is commonly used in steering-wheel armatures and instrument panel cross-car beams. The Dodge Viper’s cast magnesium front dash structure is the largest single piece of magnesium in any production car in the world.”
Various metals, including aluminum green), magnesium yellow), and press-hardened ultra-high-strength steel (maroon) can be seen on the 2017 Chrysler Pacifica at NACE. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)
A page from FCA repair procedures for the Chrysler Pacifica shows the texture that can be found on the magnesium inner liftgate. (Provided by FCA)
The magnesium (yellow) and aluminum (green) liftgate of the 2017 Chrysler Pacifica. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)