Repairer Driven News
« Back « PREV Article  |  NEXT Article »

AP: Unemployed almost equal open jobs; shops, other employers might need to up wages to compete

By on
Business Practices | Market Trends | Repair Operations

6.55 million jobs were available in March, nearly one for every one of the 6.585 million unemployed people in the country that month, based on seasonally adjusted federal data.

Longtime Associated Press economics writer Christopher Rugaber, who pointed out the impressive statistical confluence in a Tuesday article, called it a “historical anomaly.”

“Typically, there are far more unemployed people than advertised job openings — often twice as many,” he continued. “And back in July 2009, just after the Great Recession, there were 6.7 unemployed people, on average, for each open job. With that ratio now at essentially 1 to 1, the job market appears to be tilting in favor of workers and job-seekers rather than employers.”

Depending on how many positions employers added in April, the number of jobs could potentially overtake the number of unemployed. The job openings report isn’t out yet, but the number of jobless Americans fell to 6.346 million to produce an unemployment rate of 3.9 percent.

That’s the lowest unemployment rate since 2000, according to the Department of Labor.

“This is a great time to be a job seeker in America,” Labor Secretary Alexander Acosta said in a statement. “Last month, the unemployment rate fell to 3.9%, the lowest level in nearly 18 years. The unemployment rate for adult women was 3.5%, the lowest level since December 2000. Both the African-American unemployment rate and the Hispanic unemployment rate are at the lowest level ever recorded. In April, 164,000 jobs were added, including gains in goods-producing industries, such as manufacturing, mining and logging, and construction.

“America’s job creators are confident. Since President Trump’s election, nearly 3.2 million American jobs have been created. That includes nearly 800,000 jobs added since the President signed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act into law.

“In April, the rise in average weekly earnings amounts to an annual increase of approximately $1,300 – a real boost for American families. These increases do not include the millions of bonuses received by American workers since the President’s tax cuts.  Although there was an increase in wages, we would like to see more wage growth.

“Although there is room for improvement in overall labor force participation, we are encouraged to see labor force participation among those between 25 and 54 years of age rebounding, having increased from 81.3% to 82.0% since the President’s election.  This means 900,000 prime-age Americans joined the workforce since November 2016.”


Need an automotive job? Need to hire for an automotive job?
Try the SCRS-Auto Care Association-SEMA job board.

A screenshot from the Society of Collision Repair Specialists Career Center, which is part of a jobs network that includes the Auto Care Association and SEMA. (Screenshot from www.scrs.com/jobs)


Rugaber’s Associated Press report examined the idea that slower wage growth led to employees just posting more jobs because they didn’t have to pay employees much more. However, the AP quoted one economist who argued that the buyer’s market favoring job seekers meant companies will have to start raising pay.

“Employers beware,” MUFG Bank chief financial officer Chris Rupkey told the AP. “Wages have nowhere to go but up; it’s just a matter of time.”

Such high employment might make it more difficult for collision repairers to attract talented staff without offering more pay. Consider this and these other federal statistics while evaluating your pitch to prospective employees.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects the number of auto body repairer positions in the country will increase 8.5 percent from 160,400 jobs to 174,100 between 2016 and 2016 — a higher rate than the 7.4 percent growth in employment nationwide over that decade.

“Transportation equipment” painter jobs– the BLS category which includes auto body painters — are expected to grow 6.6 percent, from 58,100 to 61,900 jobs by 2026.

The government’s growth projections are interesting given the trend toward industry consolidation, predictions that smaller shops will be unable to keep pace with modern vehicle, and what is eventually likely to be a reduction in crashes tied to advanced driver assistance systems, if not outright autonomous vehicles.

According to the feds, auto body repairers made an average of $21.94 an hour in May 2017 for an average annual income of $45,630. It might be more useful in terms of calculating what to offer potential candidates (or to your staff to keep them happy) to consider percentiles.

At the median 50th percentile — meaning that half of all the repairers in the country are making more — a body technician makes $20.18 an hour for an annual wage of $41,970.

At the 75th percentile — a quarter of all the repairers in the nation make more — a technician is making $26.89 an hour. At the 90th percentile — 1 in 10 repairers still make more — our hypothetical technician makes $33.98 an hour for an annual salary of $70,670.

It’s unclear what the existence of piece rate pay plans would mean for these rates, but you get the idea.

Ironically given the tech shortage, labor rates increased very little since May 2016. The median pay rose about 1.05 percent, while average pay rose 1.01 percent. Inflation was 1.9 percent during those months.

Transportation equipment painters made an average of $22.30 an hour for $46,380 in May 2017, up 0.2 percent from May 2016. The median 50th percentile wage was was $20.12 for $41,850 a year — down 0.7 percent.

Nationally, Americans averaged $24.34 an hour for $50,620, up 2 percent — about the inflation rate. Median 50th percentile wage rose 1.74 percent to $18.12 an hour.

While benefits and various non-compensation workplace conditions matter a great deal as well, it looks like shop owners might want to evaluate their pay scales if they’re having difficulty finding qualified techs — particularly if the national employment rate remains strong.

More information:

“US job openings equal unemployed for 1st time in 2 decades”

Associated Press, May 8, 2018

Job openings, hires, and total separations by industry, seasonally adjusted

Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed May 11, 2018

Employment Situation Summary household data, seasonally adjusted

“Better Pay and Benefits Loom Large in Job Satisfaction”

Society for Human Resource Management

“Managing for Employee Retention”

Society for Human Resource Management, March 17, 2017

May 2017 Occupational Employment and Wages data for auto body repairers

May 2017 Occupational Employment and Wages data for transportation painters

Featured image: SEMA’s 2017 career event is shown. (John Huetter/Repairer Driven News)